Casement Windows vs Double Hung: Which Is Best for You?

casement windows vs double hung

Replacing your windows is one of the best ways to boost your home’s energy efficiency, security, and curb appeal, but finding the perfect window can be difficult. Knowing the difference in cost, efficiency, and functionality between casement windows vs double hung windows will make the decision clear and simple. 

If you’re in the market for replacement windows you may have already come across a few different operable window types. The most popular choices by far are casement and double hung windows for their ease of use and classic style. Deciding between the two is a matter of how you prefer to open your windows, and your need for durability, energy efficiency, and ventilation.

casement windows vs double hung

Asher Logo of Wisconsin

Explore our casement and double hung window selection at the Asher showroom or visit our website to request a free estimate for your replacement windows. 

Casement vs Double Hung Windows: What’s the Difference?

The key difference between casement and double hung windows is that casement windows operate via a crank at the base, while double hung windows operate by pushing a sash up or down. They each have their own unique benefits and drawbacks, so the best option for you depends on your needs.

To get a better understanding of how each can fit into your lifestyle, we need to go into further detail on their designs.

What is a Casement Window?

Casement windows open outward like a door swinging toward their hinged side. A handheld crank on the interior base turns the gears that swing the window until it’s perpendicular to the frame. After cranking the widow shut, a latch on the side can be closed to create an air-tight seal.

These windows are known for being easier to operate and offering clearer views than their counterparts. Casement windows, or crank out windows, are defined by these three characteristics:

  • Outward opening 
  • Crank operated
  • Unobstructed views

What is a Double Hung Window?

Double hung windows are made up of an upper and lower sash, or glass windowpane, that each slides up or down independently. Typically, the upper sash remains stationary while the lower sash is moved up or down. However, the option of having top opening windows is why most people prefer them to single hung windows in which the top is fixed in position.

Double hung windows have a more classical style as windows with sashes came onto the scene back in the 17th century. They can easily be identified by these three main elements:

  • Window panes that open vertically
  • Horizontal divider between the sashes 
  • Top opening functionality

Key Differences Between Casement and Double Hung Windows

The deciding factor for most people is whether they want windows that open outward or windows that open upward. Windows that open out offer clear views, but could interfere with window planters or other nearby elements. Windows that open upward avoid taking up extra space at the cost of a clear view. However, there’s much more to them than simply how they operate.

Understanding Cost Differences

Window replacement can be an expensive renovation to undertake so it’s important to take a look at the casement vs double hung cost comparison. Casement window costs are on average 10% more expensive than double hung windows due to the complex mechanisms involved in the crank opening.

Double hung windows are also the more widely used among the two, which leads to higher competition among manufacturers, keeping costs down. Their prices range between $500 and $1200 per window, whereas casement window prices are just 10% higher than that on average. The reason for the difference can be summarized in three key points:

  • Casement window cranks are more complex to manufacture
  • Double hung windows have more market competition
  • Casement windows have a lower demand

kitchen casement windows

Why Choose Casement Windows?

Casement windows are becoming more popular with modern homes that reflect their contemporary style. They have several advantages over double hung windows, but also a few drawbacks to consider. Making a pros-and-cons list is the perfect way to determine if casement windows are right for your home.

Casement Window Benefits

The main benefit of casement windows is their easy crank opening, which has made them popular with elderly or disabled homeowners who have difficulty lifting heavy window sashes. It’s also common to see kitchen casement windows because they are easier to open when reaching over a sink or countertop.

Casement windows also offer the best views because there is no sash that divides the window. When fully closed and locked, they create a tighter seal that is both great for temperature control and energy efficiency.

Pros of Casement Windows

  • They are easier to open and close via the crank mechanism.
  • They offer clearer views with less obstruction.
  • Their air-tight seals boost energy efficiency.

Casement Window Drawbacks

There are a few drawbacks to choosing casement windows aside from the 10% higher casement window replacement cost. The complex mechanisms involved in the crank are more likely to fail over time than any other window part. Fixing or replacing them is an option, but if it’s out of warranty that will come at a cost.

Due to their door-like opening they aren’t good candidates for most basic window air-conditioner units. Specialty A/C units are available but are more expensive than traditional ones. Depending on your needs, these few areas could be cause for concern.

Potential Cons of Casement Windows

  • Casement window costs are higher on average.
  • Their cranks are more prone to failure than other window mechanisms.
  • Basic window A/C units won’t fit in casement windows.

double hung kitchen windows

Why Choose Double Hung Windows?

Double hung windows have a classic look and feel that fit well with every home aesthetic. They are simple in design and functionality and reflect that in their pricing. There’s a good reason they are the most widely used window, but there are a few areas in which the design falls behind the competition.

Double Hung Window Benefits

Double hung windows are low maintenance and at low risk of mechanical failure due to their simplistic design. This gives them a longer lifespan on average. Combined with their lower price point, this makes them the more economical window option.

Some homeowners have even decided to start replacing casement windows with double hung when mechanical failure becomes an issue. Their functional design also accommodates most window A/C units as an added bonus for the penny-wise homeowner.

Pros of Double Hung Windows

  • They are the more affordable choice.
  • They are low maintenance and have a low risk of failure.
  • They are designed with window A/C units in mind.

Double Hung Window Drawbacks

Most homeowners have experienced the pains of cleaning double hung or single hung windows. The outer sashes can be difficult to reach, in some brands, leaving a small gap of dirt where the two windows overlap.

Normal wear and tear may also cause the lower sash on a double hung window to slide down when you want it to stay up. There are quick and easy fixes for this but a prop for your window is not everyone’s favorite design choice. Add to this the horizontal bar dividing your view and this window type has a few disadvantages.

Potential Cons of Casement Windows

  • Their outer window panes are difficult to clean in some brands.
  • Their lower sashes may refuse to stay up over time.
  • Their horizontal bars obstruct a clear view of the outdoors.

double hung windows on home front

Should You Choose Casement or Double Hung Windows?

The choice between casement or double hung windows is as much about style as it is functionality, cost, and longevity. However, it doesn’t have to all be one or the other with the available combination window stylings. You may choose to have double hung windows on your house front and casement windows in the kitchen.

Another popular choice is to have twin casement windows in the living room paired with a picture window for added light and ventilation. Whatever your design choices are, be sure to select the best quality materials and professional installation to get the most out of your window replacement.

double hung windows or casement windows

Request a Free Replacement Window Estimate from Asher 

Purchasing new windows is a big investment, which can make for a daunting choice. At Asher, we don’t operate on a good, better, best system. Instead, we only offer the highest quality products on the market, so you know you’re getting the best casement windows or double hung windows that money can buy. Visit our showroom to see our high-quality selection of Renewal by Andersen windows or request a free estimate now. For more information on window selection and home renovation, check out our blog for the latest tips and tricks.